top of page
Stock Exchange
Search

Blog Post About the Market Distortions Created by Index Funds

Writer: DMattersdorffDMattersdorff

Here is an interesting article from the Financial Times which I would like to share with you. It draws a connection between the wild trading in GameStop, Tesla, and others, with the rise of passive index investing.



If you're not interested, I understand. The gist of the story is that index funds never sell unless they experience outflows from their funds. If GameStop goes to $400, or Tesla to $900, they buy and buy, at any price. No one is actually minding the fund.


Given the $ billions flowing into index funds, this phenomenon could seriously distort prices in the marketplace, and the author suggests that we have seen such distortions already.


Ironically, as an aside, the article highlights something which I have mused about for a long time. If everyone in the world goes to index investing, it will work much less well and will create great opportunities for active investors.


Carson Block is a prominent professional short-seller. He has an axe to grind. Still, I liked his reasoning and think that it holds some explanatory power over price behavior in certain very hot stocks.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Stocks and Elections

I probably should not comment on the election.  I will likely annoy someone, maybe everyone!  But several clients have either asked me...

Comments


How to Contact the team at D. Mattersdorff LLC:

By phone: (510) 842-6060 

D. Mattersdorff LLC is a licensed investment adviser in Oregon (and California). The firm may only transact business in other states if first licensed or excluded from licensing requirements. Transacting securities or rendering investment advice for compensation will not be made prior to compliance with licensing requirements or a valid exclusion from licensing.

© 2008-2025 D. Mattersdorff LLC. All rights Reserved.

bottom of page